Find hotels near Waterlemon Cay, St. John from SAR 1,435

"We stayed at Papaya Moon for two weeks at the beginning of March 2025 in the “Place in the Sun” suite. Simply paradise. The mountaintop views and breezes are heavenly. It is a very private location, surrounded by Sue’s beautiful gardens and the natural beauty of the island. You have your option of lots of outdoor activities – swimming, kayaking, snorkeling in turquoise waters; hiking the many trails that range from challenging to easy-going strolls. Or you can relax on the deck and gaze at sea and sky every time you look up from your book. We’d call Coral Bay the quiet side of the island, in contrast to the busier beaches closer to Cruz Bay. Coral Bay has some good places to eat and hear music, and a pottery studio/gallery/gift shop with work by local artists. Ron and Sue are wonderful hosts. It was a pleasure to meet them and learn about their experiences on St. John and obvious devotion to their island community. All the amenities in the description are accurate – clean, well-equipped, wifi, nice little kitchen, etc. We were also able to take a look at the other suite, and it is equally lovely.— Cecilia V. & Carl F. 3/22/2025"

"We had the most incredible Island vacation. The panoramic views are even better in person. The house was a laid-back beachy island vibe. To be clear, this is a Coral Bay Island home, not the Ritz, but that’s everything we loved about it. There is no air conditioning in the main living area, which was not a problem at all. We opened up the doors and let the breeze come in and enjoyed the air conditioning in the bedrooms. We found the beds to be very comfortable and I slept great the entire time. We ate breakfast, looking out over the water and swam in the afternoon taking in the views. You absolutely need four-wheel-drive to get up to the house but it is in close proximity to everything in Coral Bay. It takes about 25 minutes to Cruz Bay. We much preferred staying in Coral Bay. It was exactly what we were looking for. Much quieter with a local feel. Greg was probably the kindest and most intentional host we’ve ever encountered. We had, unfortunately, gotten a flat tire on our rental car and he immediately came to help us change it. Nothing was too much. We would definitely love to come back one day. The one thing I would say to be aware of is that it’s very expensive on the island so we picked up our car from the airport and bought groceries on St. Thomas and brought them over. We were so glad we did. Thanks so much for a dream vacation."

"In Harmony is a perfect retreat for two people. The view is gorgeous and the two decks (covered and uncovered) allow you to see it rain or shine. The uncovered deck also has a lovely hot tub and two chaise lounges from which you can see the view or watch for shooting stars at night! The house is equipped with everything you need and if there is something you cannot find, Paul, the manager will have it to you immediately. Both Greg, the owner, and Paul were there to answer any questions and help with suggestions on restaurants and grocery stores. We surely hope to return to this lovely home again!"

"10th visit to STJ and Husband and I had a first kid free get away and Salty Kisses was perfect! Great chairs, yeti cooler, comfy bed, plenty of nice towels, well appointed kitchen, great grill, and lovely decor!!!! Peaceful and perfect! Thank you Amanda!! "

"We loved our stay at this home in Coral Bay. It is located on the quieter side of the island and in short drives to the main beaches and sights. The home is extremely clean, well appointed, and A/C works great. Communication with the property manager, Dwight, was fantastic and he checked in with us throughout our stay to make sure everything was going well. The pool is a little larger than I expected from the pictures which was a nice bonus. Views are phenomenal and we enjoyed just hanging out on the decks. The only slightly annoying aspect of the property is that you have to go outside to get between levels, but really it's not a huge deal. Would definitely stay here again! "

"My wife and I chose St John and Bambooshay to celebrate our 60th birthdays that fall only a few weeks apart. We could not be more pleased with the home! The pictures understate the beauty of the home and stunning views. The changing light of the sun during the day brought a beautiful new view of Coral Bay to enjoy every hour. The home is wonderfully equipped with all the little details, kitchen equipment etc to allow us to feel at home immediately. The pool and separate hot tub were used every day and the natural trees, bamboo and shrubs surrounded the home in privacy and added to the secluded, remote experience of Coral Bay we were seeking. We are animal lovers and so the plethora of chickens and goats roaming about was as added bonus. The property manager, Tammy, was super helpful and attentive before, during and after our stay. Would love to return one day! Thank you Scott for sharing your amazing home! "

"Enjoyed relaxing on the porch, loved the pool, cool outdoor shower and amazing views"

"This home is absolutely beautiful! We loved the spacious Lanai with the amazing views. This home was fully stocked with everything you could possibly need for your trip, I have rented over 20 VRBO's and no other property comes close to offering what this home does. The property was very clean and the beds were comfortable. It was extremely nice to have a washer and dryer as well. The property manager, Paul, lives near by and is a great guy and is super helpful as he has lived on island for quite some time. If you are looking for a great experience in a peaceful community look no further! "

"Excellent property, the pool and hot tub were a plus. The villa was clean and had plenty of accommodations. The location is perfect and all parts of the island are within a short drive. We were very happy with the communication prior to the visit and the check-in process."