Search Vacation Homes in Nelliston

"We were looking for a quiet, peaceful, lakefront cottage and Firefly Lodge delivered. We enjoyed coffee on the dock every morning and were joined by the ducks and loons. The highlight for us was watching the supermoon rise over the lake. It seemed like you could reach out and touch it. The owners were great and made sure we had no problems. We hope to be able to visit again"

"I cannot recommend this place enough. Clean, spacious, well stocked and quiet...you cant ask for much more. Beds were comfortable, bathrooms were clean with good water pressure. Not too far from Cooperstown but far enough that you didnt have to deal with the crowds. If you're coming for All-Stars or Dreams Park, or just to visit the HOF, this would be a great place to stay. And the title of the review is exactly what my son said when we brought him there from the baseball tournament, I guess...

"The stay was very cozy and very relaxed! A perfect getaway from a busy routine!!"

"Otsego Lake is a stunner! Our best lake experience that we have had as a family to date. The property was really nice and afforded our family everything we needed for a couple of weeks. "

"Our son played at Cooperstown AllStars for a week. It was about a 35 minute drive from there. It was quiet, spacious and accommodating to our two dogs. It was a nice escape. "

"1890s Elegant mansion with great bones and almost completely restored. Pool would be big plus in summer and game room definitely a plus, though some equipment needed repair. Great location for our short family reunion of 6 adults and 3 tweens. Would worry about kids less than 10 or limited mobility folks as stairs quite tight or spirally and high. Does have first floor bedroom but a bit of distance to the single well appointed bath on that floor. Kitchen quite well equipped and even had a wide...

"Super clean, lovely views, is stocked with pretty much anything you could think of, supermarket real close .."

"Rustic, authentic Adirondack Lake House with plenty of room for the family. Plenty of outdoor equipment including a great dock to fish off of. Indoors was cozy with plenty of warming options on chilly nights and rainy days. Kitchen was well equipped and very spacious. Multiple dining areas including a very nice sun porch. Would definitely recommend if you are looking for authentic lake house experience."

"This is our 3rd time to stay here. The home is very clean, comfortable and convenient!!!"

"Very nice home would stay there again on Friday"

"Property was clean, comfortable and the view was terrific. The only issue we had was they also had a tenant in a garage apartment. Would have been nice to know we were sharing the property. We saw a light on in the garage and went to shut it off when we saw someonecin threethere was"

"A guys trip to Cooperstown was topped off with a wonderful experience relaxing in this beautiful house. Lots of beds and space to spread out for our group of 6. Beautiful scenery off the back porch. Quiet. But the best part of it all was the hospitality from our hosts. They made sure we had all we needed to make our stay easy and comfortable. Would definitely stay here again and the drive to Cooperstown was scenic and simple! "