Search Cottages in Nelliston

"Older motor style hotel but kept up and clean. I enjoyed the indoor pool (there's an outdoor also). Staff was great."

"Beautiful setting and well maintained. Modern version of a 50s motel on a lake. Only downside is lack of cell service except for Verizon customers. Still worth a visit!"

"Conviently locted. Clean"

"The staff there were excellent. They had boats available to check out for free and it was a lovely stay overall."

"quiet and with a good location. I recommend."

"The owner of this inn was absolutely fantastic. He was a delight to interact with and was wonderful with our children. I recommend this inn HIGHLY to families, and with the baseball field (and bats and balls) it is a perfect accompaniment to a nearby Cooperstown HOF visit. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED."

"We love the pool area especially for the children , water is clean and well kept area. It’s a cozy atmosphere there . "

"Really nice & clean. Historical property, you will love it. We thought it was very cool."

"OK, first an important note: I planned a trip to the Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown and I made a reservation at the Hayden Creek Inn for a single person. My son and grandson decided to Join me, but the Hayden Creek Inn was sold out and my room was too small to add two cots. I called the owner (Austin), who super-graciously gave me a room with two queen beds in his other, nearby, property called the Meadowlark Inn. So this review is really about the Meadowlark Inn, but much of it applies to the Hayden Creek Inn because they share the same super-friendly and helpful owner."