Find all hotels by Independent in Livingston Manor, NY from SAR 446

"Very nice room,very clean,friendly staff"

"everything was perfect"

"Had a quiet and lovely stay! "

"My wife and I had a great time staying at Callicoon Hills. All of the staff was extremely attentive and hospitable. We are definitely going back!"

"The cottage at Stratton Falls was amazing. It’s a destination."

"The rooms and bathrooms are impeccable. A convenient and affordable hotel."

"amazing resort "

"The service was excellent, the room was perfect (the splitter/HVAC units on the ground outside the room were a bit noisy - but not unpleasant at least for me - however for future guests, you may want to consider muffling the sound if possible), immaculate, bed was very comfortable, TV was excellent (theatre-grade), the Exec Chef at the Shandaken is definitely "Michelin-grade", outstanding cuisine, complimentary breakfast menu was fantastic, the entire management/service team was/is "top-notch". Views are excellent, fire pits are a definite plus and the pool/tennis court look inviting (come summertime). The 3 cottages look like a wonderful option for extended stays with the whole family/friends! Thanks again!!! Happy 2025 to ALL of YOU!!!"

"Inexpensive, Clean, amazing staff, huge room, convenient location to dining, most comfortable bed and pillows and parking. You can't go wrong, because I still can't believe I paid next to nothing just to lay my head after DJing a New Years Eve event in the area. I was well pleased and will certainly be back when I have to DJ in that area again, because most of my events in that area mostly ends between midnight - 2 AM in the morning and I hate traveling back to the NYC that late and far. "