Find Historic Hotels in Allegheny Plateau, NY

"Fantastic inn and innkeepers. Could not have been more pleased and Margie and Jay were very welcoming and helpful. Spotless and comfortable. A mini art gallery and history museum too. Breakfast was delicious. "

"Gail, the innkeeper, made us feel very welcome. She was very nice and very informative. The breakfast was great. The room was big and quiet. We like the stand alone shower. Great stay. Great location. We enjoyed Geneseo and Gail helped us with that."

"We felt as if we were in Downton Abby. The guest rooms were ALL beautiful. The sitting room and library had nice cosy fire places with soft relaxing music in the background. Each breakfast in the lovely dinning area was a five star event starting with a fresh fruit cup along with delicious pastries and THEN the hot meal was not only artistically displayed but a gastronomical delight…ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS. On top of all of this the host and her helper were so gracious and extremely kind. As you...

"Owner provided breakfast gift card because owner was out of town. Much appreciated!"

"Awesome view of the lake….bald eagle soaring overhead, cozy, campy feeling cottage. What more could you ask for?"

"We were disappointed almost as soon as we entered our room. Although it was clean, it was crammed full of furniture with little floor space. The bathroom sink did not drain. We were told by the owner that previous customers had poured cereal and coffee grounds down the sink. It would have been preferred that she had assigned a different room if she knew that."

"If you like old houses this one is a gem to explore with a great mix of old and modern. Our family included grandparents attending SUNY Geneseo graduation. House big enough to have space for alone time and to gather for a meal in the great dining room. Highly recommend!!!"

"Quiet and close to I-86 highway"