Find 2 Star Hotels in Fire Island, NY from SAR 367

"The property is a revamped type of place that you can tell has some worn out characteristics about it but overall it is convenient and clean enough and breakfast was a good amount of to go items. Good enough for the price "

"Breakfast buffet and gym were especially good. Check-in was rather slow. Would have been nice to see evidence of recycling options and less use of non-reusables at breakfast buffet. "

"Everything "

"Friendly staff and well kept. "

"Quiet and clean. Easy check in process, great amenities."

"Clean, quiet, nice service. The most important thing is that they have a coffee machine. 😊"

"Great location and staff !"

"It’s a beautiful place, very well organized. The staff were very welcoming and helpful. It was great to see people who looked happy in their job. Kind little touches like 24 hour coffee, hot water and snacks. The shower had great pressure and an endless supply of hot water. And being within walking distance of the Paramount was awesome. Also, their breakfast…👍👍👍👍👍👍👍"

"Staff was responsive to requests "

"Room was clean and comfortable. Bathroom door needed to be replaced as the bottom of the door is destroyed "

"Very nice place to stay--Clean, comfortable and the staff is very friendly and helpful. Super convenient location too, close to JFK. I was there for 11 nights and wouldn't hesitate to book this hotel again when in the Long Island area."

"Totally fine for what we needed overnight. Management was helpful, Room was tidy, area is quiet. Our TV didn't work though, had to switch rooms and shower had nowhere to store soap and shampoo. Since it's near a pond, there are lots of geese. Watch where you step, there are goose droppings everywhere on the property."