Search Apartments in Shelter Island Heights

"Great place great price nice people. This is an apartment in someone’s house, they were welcoming and helpful. Definitely would stay here again."

"Beautiful property is in a safe walkable area near restaurants and shops. Off street parking was easy to find. Lovely garden path leads you to the front door. Interior flight of curved/circular stairs takes you up one flight to door. Maybe tricky for someone with mobility issues. Bedrooms and one bath were clean, nicely decorated and well stocked with the essentials including soaps, hair dryer and tissues. Kitchen was bright. Please note there is minimal counter space but well stocked...

"There was a complete misunderstanding about the houses. The listing doesn’t say upstairs or downstairs so we were in the wrong part of the house and the second building wasn’t one of the places to stay in so someone had to leave for no reason for the miscommunication cause we had the wrong part of the house. There needs to be more in the listing stating upstairs and down stairs. We got the place for 8 and the bedrooms couldn’t sleep 8 without guys doubling up in beds. It wasn’t intentional to be...

"Being literally on the beach with resident access to chairs towels umbrellas and snacks is really awesome."

"We loved this quiet and cozy apartment! It was very clean, updated, and easy to access. John was in communication and even provided dining recommendations. We walked into Greenport center every day and it was the perfect location. We hope to be back again!"

"Maritza and John were very friendly hosts and we even met their lovely dog Sara! Central location to Greenport. You have access to the top floor of the house where it is both homely and inviting. Would stay here again"

"We stayed here while visiting our son. The place looks brand new, right on the water, super quiet (I don't think we heard a noise the whole weekend). Nice community/area, would definitely stay here again. Ned was super nice and gave us two great recommendations for dinner. "

"We meet Manny when we arrived at the property and he showed us around and gave us great tips on things to do and beaches to visit, his wife found out it was my wife's birthday and she made her a special dessert. It was a great time. "

"The property was perfect for two people who want a cozy space, perfect location, and a wonderful and helpful owner. Would definitely return."

"Very nice spot for a couple to stay. Fully equipped and thoughtfully laid out. Comfortable bed. Updated in all ways. Exceptionally clean and well stocked. Very convenient to downtown and extremely walkable."