Search Villas in Shelter Island Heights

"Absolutely loved staying here. Katie was super helpful and my group had an amazing time. The house is plenty big for big groups. While my group was supposed to be 16, we only had 8 but it felt even more special! Everyone had their own rooms & thoroughly enjoyed their time. Thank you for being an incredible host, Katie! "

"Very nice house In great shape and outstanding pool area."

"This is a gorgeous, comfortable, well-maintained property and everything was perfect. We all agreed we would love to stay here again! Check-out was listed as 10 AM but we pre-arranged to check-out at noon for no additional charge. "

"This is a large and extremely comfortable house. The owner is attentive to any questions you might have. LOVED spending time there. "

"My family and I could not have picked a more beautiful home to celebrate my mom’s 80th birthday! We had a few rainy days and two 18 year olds, who were more than happy to stay at home and take advantage of the pool table, ping pong table, full gym…everything! Conny was so warm and welcoming in all of her communications. Her home is absolutely stunning! It was beautifully decorated and had many spaces to gather as a family. We spent every morning having coffee on the front porch and afternoons in...