Find 3 Star Hotels in Shelter Island Heights, NY from SAR 510

"Great overall! Just wish there was more parking available."

"Quick impromptu perfect get away the night before Easter. I've stayed here before in the main building, and wasn't a huge fan..... Staying in the building on the LI sound was spectacular! It was beautiful, updated, and had all the luxury comforts of home. Full size kitchen, washer and dryer, wine fridge, gas stove, microwave, & fireplace. I loved falling asleep while listening to the waves hitting the shoreline at night, & the bed was extremely comfortable! My daughter met me with...

"Above and beyond what we expected for an off-season stay! Beautifully maintained property, gorgeous view from our room's balcony, kind and helpful staff. Will definitely be back in the near future."

"Very peaceful experience I would suggest this anyone looking for a relax get away close to home "

"Arrived last minute and was taken care of by the staff immediately "

"The staff were wonderful. Loved breakfast. Super dog friendly. Easy parking. "

"It was a very relaxing and enjoyable couple of days."

"It’s okay for a night or two not a first or second choice however. The cosmetic upgrade for this property is okay in comparison to the cost of the stay. The doors only have a button lock on some cottages and seems like the original handle, it was loose and the key was sticking. Though I was accommodated with a different cottage that had a padlock as well, there was a visible mold and moisture issue causing the laminate floors to bubble. Some groundskeeping opportunities with pathways and the...