Find 2 Star Hotels in Fishers Island, NY from SAR 195

"Everything was good. I enjoyed staying here."

"Very nice property…beautiful place with awesome people…special mention to all the kitchen staff and front desk staff…the rooms were huge and with excellent attention to details…the bathrooms were super clean…overall a very satisfying stay…"

"It was adequate for the price, did not have coffee maker in the room or hairdryers. But the bee was comfortable and the room was clean"

"Has shuttle for Mohegan on weekends "

"We were happy with the hotel. Room was comfortable and staff was very helpful. Nice family environment"

"Lovi was very helpful. "

"If you truly want to experience the quaintness of Mystic, this is your place. It’s clean, safe and the owner and staff are delightful! 10 out of 10 recommend!!! "

"Great deal for a Saturday night. GF and I went to a show at Foxwoods and stayed here. The room was very clean and the window view was very pleasant while laying in bed. Microwave and fridge were awesome. My only complaint is that the bed was not that comfortable but we would stay here again given the affordable price."

"NA"

"It was a good place to stay for 6 nights but they could upgrade their pillows and mop the pool area because there was lots of hair on the floor. The pool was excellent nice and warm. Alot of choices in breakfast buffet"

"Is a good place"

"Check in was fast and easy, room was clean comfortable and updated and the staff was courteous friendly and helpful. Looking forward to returning during the summer!"