Find 2 Star Hotels in Fishers Island, NY from SAR 185

"Get there late but it was worth it all i sleep so well"

"Quiet"

"Simple, straightforward hotel. Property was clean and well maintained. Easy parking, easy access to highway. On-site restaurant was small but ok. Would stay again."

"Property not maintained well, but convenient to aquarium and village. Bed comfortable. Need new rug and bathroom needs more light and light fixture needs to be cleaned. Shower head great! Front desk friendly. Diner good. Overhaul price good."

"Very comfortable "

"I needed an inexpensive room for a couple of nights while in town on business. This place was exactly that. The good: Heat works well, plenty of parking, front desk staff was very friendly and welcoming, bed was comfortable, room was clean, it was quiet, I felt safe at night. The bad: it's an old property and the rooms could use updating, fresh paint, new carpeting, etc. All in all, the Rodeway Inn was exactly what I was looking for and I would stay again. "

"The buildings needed some basic maintenance on the outside - paint, repairs to some old wood, etc. But the room was nice quite large. And in goof condition. The jetted in-room tub wss wonderful. The breakfast was just a few carry-out type items but they didn't promise a full breakfast so it was OK. Convenient to Mystic Area. "

"Stay was good for price. Nice to have restaurant and bar on premise. Very good food and good service."

"Good "

"Very well kept hotel. Nice atmosphere and very nice staff."

"Spent an overnight with my wife. The entrance to the Tabor Inn was clean and landscaped very nicely. The woman at the check in desk explained to call the desk in tje morning and breakfast would be delivered to our room,walked us to our room after check in. Then room was so cozy and quaint and comfortable. The most appreciated part was with as close as we were to a main road, there rooms were so quiet. Had an amazingly quiet and comfortable stay. Will definitely be back."

"Great area "