Search Guest Houses in Fishers Island

Plan, book, stay with confidence

Be picky

Search almost a million properties worldwide

Treat yourself

Change your mind

Book hotels with free cancellation

Compare 11 Guest Houses in Fishers Island with updated reviews, rates, and availability.

"This small cottage had amazings views of the harbor. My wife and I are experienced travelers and we both agreed this is the cleanest place we've ever stayed in! "

SAR 730 total

includes taxes & fees

6 Jan - 7 Jan

Relax and enjoy; this is your private backyard year round.

"This over-garage apartment was beautifully appointed and incredibly comfortable. Walk out the door and you are at the private beach in less than 2 minutes. Lovely water views from the living room. The host had so many thoughtful extras like beach towels and sand toys, water bottles in the refrigerator, etc. We wojle absolutely recommend."

"Really mice"

Ready to sleep like a baby on this well-appointed King-sized, memory foam Casper mattress? Yes, it is super comfy!

Note: The bedroom area has a partition wall on the left with an open ceiling separating the living and bedroom- open concept.

"Enchanting week staying at the Smith Cottage with my partner and canine old boy. Immaculate is an understatement for the cottage-it was beautiful, cozy and it is mind-boggling to me just how attentive, intuitive and thoughtful our host Debbie is. I cannot wait to return next September. Everything both inside and outside this property was great, including the beautiful fire pit under the harvest moon at night. Thank you Debbie, for a much needed wonderful stay. "

SAR 1,255 total

includes taxes & fees

6 Jan - 7 Jan

"We stayed for a long weekend to see the Christmas boat parade. This property is perfectly located and walking distance to everything! The house was in great condition and very clean. It had everything you would possibly need. Our next trip to Mystic will definitely be here."

"Such an amazing find! I love it and can’t wait to come back! We’ve stayed before and now it’s part of what we love about Mystic. "

SAR 916 total

includes taxes & fees

12 Jan - 13 Jan

Two-unit house. One side is rented, and the owner lives on the other side.

"Jeff and Sarah were very pleasant hosts. They were attentive and kept up with communication. They even offered us to ride their bikes to roam around Stonington. The place was very clean and spacious. I would come back without any hesitations. You should too. Thank you Jeff and Sarah."