Search Vacation Homes in Fishers Island

"Super easy to park and get into the place with instructions sent in plenty of time. Kitchen had all of the things we needed. This is an old home -- the stairs are steep and the floors are all wonky. But it has lots of character and is comfortable! The house is right on the road so you can hear traffic, but at night it was quiet. Heating system was easy to figure out. Hot water was abundant and water pressure is excellent. Host responded immediately to my questions. The St Patrick's...

"Hotel didn’t have out reservation even after we had paid for it - took an hour to check in at midnight - parking lot was full of random activity and people all hours of night and hall ways smelled like weed. Clientele was shady and co within of hotel rooms and surrounding area was dirty, worn out, in need of maintenance and overall place was a dump. Checked out a day early and forfeited a night because place was so disgusting. Expedia needs to remove them from hotel options and do a better job...

"We loved being able to walk right into town. The home has vintage character and fun design. Everything we needed was there to make a meal when we weren't enjoying the local restaurants. "

"On the sixth anniversary of our daughter’s passing, we got together with another daughter, her husband, and their Australian shepherd dog for family time. It was chilly, but we enjoyed our time together. Mystic is a lovely spot, even in early March. Your home was a lovely oasis for us. Thank you!"

"Pulling into the driveway of this home, you feel like you are in Watch Hill. The stone walls, perfectly maintained landscaping, outdoor fire pit and porch exude luxury resort. The well appointed kitchen, large dining table and seating areas provide ample space to relax and enjoy meals. So happy to have found a wonderful place close to the beach and everything you need."

"Unbeatable location close to the shops and restaurants in Mystic with a river view from certain windows. Christopher was quick to respond in all communications. "

"Had a fun couple nights here! Robynne was friendly and responsive. I would recommend this location for a nice visit to Mystic."