Search Vacation Homes in Fishers Island

Plan, book, stay with confidence

Be picky

Search almost a million properties worldwide

Treat yourself

Change your mind

Book hotels with free cancellation

Compare 693 Vacation Homes in Fishers Island with updated reviews, rates, and availability.

"Totally hit the mark! This was a stay for family members for a wedding, Thanksgiving and a homecoming from a military family member. We had about 20 people for Thanksgiving and the open Floorplan dining area was perfect. We loved all the open views from windows and doors"

"From the first communication re the property, the host was very responsive and helpful. We were looking for a property for a family fun weekend with plans to go to Mohegan. Very convenient location and a quick uber to the casino. From the moment we arrived, it was clear that the owners of the property take great pride in their home- as well as the guests staying. The home was like new- clean- comfortable- spacious- cozy- and had everything we needed. The beds were comfortable, bathrooms...

SAR 1,284 total

includes taxes & fees

12 Jan - 13 Jan

Groton Vacation Rental | 4BR | 3.5BA | 3,580 Sq Ft | 3 Steps to Enter

"We were 11 family members staying for 5 days. The hosts were so accommodating and gracious. The home is gorgeous and exceptionally appointed it had everything we needed and then some. We would 100% stay there again and recommend it to anyone. "

20x40' pool has two shallow ends and stadium steps on both sides

"Nothing negative to say. The owner came to greet us on our arrival, and showed us around the property. The house and grounds are family friendly with safety features for toddlers. Plenty of room for a large group. Parking for one car at the beach, and a short walk if all cannot fit in the car. The two outdoor showers are great when returning from the beach."

"everyone associated with the property is great from owner to local mananger. house is quiet and on a beautiful piece of property"

"A group of friends and I stayed at this property for a weekend and absolutely loved it! The access to the water is amazing, plus the sleeping accommodations are perfect for lots of people. The kitchen was also very well equipped and great for cooking for a large group. We had a great time, and I would highly recommend this to anyone! Hope to return soon."

"Pulling into the driveway of this home, you feel like you are in Watch Hill. The stone walls, perfectly maintained landscaping, outdoor fire pit and porch exude luxury resort. The well appointed kitchen, large dining table and seating areas provide ample space to relax and enjoy meals. So happy to have found a wonderful place close to the beach and everything you need."

"We thoroughly enjoyed staying here, short walk to town, beautiful scenery, quiet and clean. "

"A group of friends and family from NJ and Boston stayed as a reunion before the craziness of the holidays. The house, the location, the weather, everything was incredible from start to finish. Just minutes away walking from plenty of restaurants and bars! The hosts came with plenty of recommendations, and helped make our decision for dining for the weekend. Definitely would recommend this property!! "

"Had a Wonderful Time !! Ryan is great , was available to help at any time .. House is beautiful Very comfortable. Great location .. just as nice as the photos .. Very Clean , Modern and super convenient to town. Ditch Plains and of course Montauk Downs Loved It !!!"

"We loved being next door to Ocean Beach."

New Teak Lounge Chairs, Decking and Pool Liner

"We were in the Hamptons to celebrate my sisters upcoming wedding and had a fantastic time in our rental the only complaint we had was that wish we were there longer!"

"I’m grateful we found a property that fit our family size. We wanted to introduce my family to CT and be their tour guide. The house itself needs some tlc. Judge for yourself. I personally wouldn’t choose this again. "

"Loved this sweet cozy house in the middle of town! Couldn’t ask for a better location, just steps from the village! Beautiful well appointed house with absolutely everything you need to be comfortable. Wonderful host and communication. Would definitely come back for a longer stay!"

"Susan's place was perfect for my family to visit the neighborhood where I grew up! It was clean, comfortable and had everything we needed. It's also a few steps from the beach and the amenities GNB has to offer."

"We gathered with extended family for a few nights in October. Cousins, second cousins, aunts, uncles, and a 95-year old great grandmother came together here for a few nights while attending a nearby wedding. This house (really two adjoining townhomes) had it all. Beautifully appointed. Plenty of space (for people AND cars--we had six). Kid and pet friendly (gates for the stairs, high chairs and pack-n-plays, step stools in the bathrooms so kids can reach the faucets). It was amazing. Things I am...

"Perfect location, very clean, nicely decorated. We were totally pleased."

Living room with unobstructed water views on three sides

"Awesome property with everything you need for a great getaway. European chic touches throughout and a location that is just fantastic!! Spectacular Sunrises on the deck with breakfast overlooking Orient Harbor, Bug Light, and Shelter Island are mesmerizing. The view and the setting just never gets old-a real gem!! Nicole was terrific to deal with - we’ll be back!!"

"The house was absolutely adorable and had everything we needed. Izzy was very communicative and made the entire experience easy. My family and I really couldn't have had a more pleasant stay. Thank you!"