Search Cottages in Sister Bay

"The front desk staff were professional and friendly. Check in and checkout was a breeze it didn't take long at all. The room i stayed in was very inviting and comfortable. I did stay at a time were it wasnt busy, but the noise level was good. I was very impressed with how clean my room and every where else on the property inside and out! "

"Open Hearth Lodge is an awesome place to stay. The entire staff is great!!! There's gas fire pits that are lit every night. Cornhole is available. It's an awesome place to stay!"

"I liked the living room and bedroom."

"Reception was friendly and welcoming. The pool area and the playground were very clean and well kept, the rooms’ temperature control, fireplace, dishwasher, oven…all worked well. All the pans, pots, dishes and silverware we needed were included. Comfy beds and overall cozy atmosphere. The place is dated but well kept. The game room was very small (three arcade games, one foosball table). "

"Fantastic, friendly staff! "

"This place sits on some lovely acreage and overlooks the bay. The area is quiet and rooms were quite nice. They are finishing up some renovations and the updates are just perfect. Breakfast on the weekends, while not fancy, was definitely filling. During the week it's grab and go breakfast, but with good options, some to heat up in the microwave, some cold breakfast options. Fruit was always available. You can walk to town on the road or get there on the path through the forest. We walked to a lot of places in town from this spot. The staff was so friendly and nice, too!"

"We absolutely loved our week in the Beechwood Cottage! The property was clean and well maintained, with lots of thoughtful touches that reflect the host Megan’s commitment to the overall guest experience. The property was exactly as expected from provided pictures and descriptions, the location was secluded enough to be peaceful while also providing easy access to all Door County has to offer, and communication was clear, helpful, and responsive throughout the whole experience. Loved staying here and will definitely be returning in the future!"

"Clean property, nice amenities, wonderful staff!"

"Had a great few days in Sister Bay with my wife and our two dogs. Great time!!"