Find all hotels by Independent in Shelter Island, NY from SAR 259

"Location is amazing even during the off season "

"The property is great but the older part could really use an update/redresh! Smart TVs would be nice!"

"Property was beautiful, view overlooking the area was great! Parking was convenient and there were charging spots for electric cars! "

"The hotel is majestic and on the water with beautiful views. The staff was without exception incredibly attentive and friendly- from Sara and Matthew at the front desk to the gentleman who helped us with the fireplace to Mike and the other valets who took care of the car. Wonderful experience!"

"Great place an convenient for the fishing trip we were going on I’m going to make it my place to stay when I come back for years to come "

"If you ever planing on staying in a hotel Southampton area don’t look any farther. You will be blown away beyond your expectations. I felt like at home away from home. It’s a hidden gem. Experience it yourself "

"Great place to stay "

"All very good!"

"Exelente "