Search Vacation Homes in New Castle

Plan, book, stay with confidence

Be picky

Search almost a million properties worldwide

Treat yourself

Change your mind

Book hotels with free cancellation

Compare 68 Vacation Homes in New Castle with updated reviews, rates, and availability.

"My father, husband, children (21, 16), their two friends (19, 18) and myself all immensely enjoyed our stay. We grew up in neighboring Henry County, so we were somewhat familiar with this area even though we had not been here in several years. We needed accommodations as we had a family wedding to attend this particular weekend, and the property was absolutely perfect for us to stay the weekend and beyond. Nestled into the woods, we enjoyed the comforts of tranquility and privacy, along with...

"Our family was very pleased with this property. It was convenient, clean and comfortable. Just what we needed to spend a few days with family over Thanksgiving. We definitely would consider booking again. "

SAR 1,043 total

includes taxes & fees

26 Dec - 27 Dec

"I am picky and this home was perfectly clean, very convenient, easy checkin/check out, and just in general a very nice place to stay while visiting family in town. Loved and appreciated the little coffee bar :) We would and probably will book again. "

SAR 751 total

includes taxes & fees

28 Dec - 29 Dec

"We traveled to Muncie for a family wedding and were so happy to have found Kyle and Shannah’s place. It was clean, in a quiet neighborhood, and close to Ball State. The hosts were quick and easy to communicate with! We would happily stay there again."

"We found this home to be very well supplied and clean. It was just the perfect place for us to gather for Thanksgiving. Its very comfy-cozy and in a nice neighborhood. The only thing of note is that the upstairs bathroom fan is noisy and we were not left towel sets for the shower in the downstairs bath. However, since there's a washer and dryer, we just washed towels to fix that. Would highly recommend this home."

"This place was located close to the main drag with plenty of stores and restaurants. Owner was on top of responding with any correspondence. It was very clean and organized! No need to bring anything from home but your personal belonings."

"Very nice house in the heart of Fortville. House was clean and everything we needed. Owners stayed in communication and were great. Check in process was smooth and easy. Would definitely stay again."

"My husband, son, and I stayed here the weekend of our daughter’s graduation from Miami University. It was so cute and easy to access. The communication was awesome and check in/check out process was simple. Would definitely recommend."

Hagerstown Vacation Rental | 3BR | 3.5BA | 1 Step to Enter | 1,800 Sq Ft

"This property was fantastic and had all the amenities we were looking for in a long weekend away. "

Farmhouse Kitchen, Labeled Cabinets with All Supplies

"This listing was just as advertised. A lot of amenities, very clean, close to the location we needed to be in. A very fun house to stay in."

"Loved all the space & the fact that it was child friendly!"

Our sofas are plush, comfortable and perfect for taking a load off after a day spent.

"This place is a gem! Don't let the street it is on fool you. It's an older neighborhood but felt very safe. The house was super clean and had everything you could want. Kind bed was very comfortable (I asked what kind of mattress it had it was so great). Close enought to downtown to grab a bite or poke around. We were there for a wedding so we didn't get to spend much time at the house but would stay there again! Hosts are great communicators."

SAR 879 total

includes taxes & fees

29 Dec - 30 Dec

Everything you ever want! Arcade, Hot Tub, Popcorn themed movie bar, over 40 board games, Claw soaking tub, King bed, Fireplace, Bunk beds, Kids room, Full Kitchen and much more!

Our living room includes modern design, high-speed internet, and a plush sofa and chairs!

"😃"

"The house was beautiful and so interesting! The owners were very responsive to our questions. We really enjoyed our stay!"

SAR 1,250 total

includes taxes & fees

24 Dec - 25 Dec

"We were in town for a family wedding. We had a total party of eight. This property was absolutely perfect for what we needed and the price was far more reasonable than four separate hotel rooms. It was very well stocked. The setting is rural, surrounded by farmland and fields but it is only a 10 minute drive from town. Best of both worlds. The renovations were not an issue for us and I can't wait to see the finished product once completed. Overall 10/10. "

SAR 1,439 total

includes taxes & fees

3 Jan - 4 January 2025

"I originally booked this as a place to stay after we went to the Taylor Swift concert in Indianapolis. It’s about a 15-minute drive off the freeway and I passed through a couple of small towns to get to our destination. One would never guess that this lies hidden within this building. We thoroughly enjoyed it and have talked about a girls’ trip here in the future. I would stay here again."

SAR 2,886 total

includes taxes & fees

28 Dec - 29 Dec

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Other property types in New Castle

2 bedroom loft downtown condo with high ceilings, tasteful art, modern features.

"Everything was perfect! The host had the lights turned on and made us feel right at home. The unit had everything we needed. After a long drive up from Florida we settled right in!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️"

"The firepit was great, with the stars at night and the solitude. The cabin was clean and had everything anyone would need. My wife and I have traveled all our time together 48 years. This was the best ever!!!!!. We will be back again. God Bless."