Find all hotels by Independent in Gilboa, NY from SAR 324

"The property is beautiful from the artfully crafted rooms to the gorgeous surroundings including the trail to the onsite waterfall. Being able to reserve the hot tub and sauna was another higlight of this trip. It was very relaxing. The staff was wonderfully. Chuck was able to give us a brief tour of a couple of the cottages (my husband and I stayed in the Mill of the Frozen Falls room in the mansion). The attention to detail of the decor in theae cottages is truly amazing. This was our second visit having previously stayed at The Roxbury Motel. We will definitely be back."

"Loved our stay. The rooms are large, freshly renovated, stylish and affordable. We loved being able to see the mountains directly from our window. They also have a lovely restaurant and library. I’m surprised they don’t host events. "

"The Colonial Motel was extremely clean and fresh. Staff was very nice and friendly. All items available for a pleasant stay."

"Room is clean but dated. Parking lot has huge pot holes in it "

"Very very clean nicely painted and smelled very good . Restrooms were spotless . Front desk she was great helpful and friendly "

"The property was beautiful with its location and design. It was very inviting as well with a basket for smores waiting in the fridge. 10/10 would book again if the chance is available."

"Great home, great location and great owner. Couldn't have asked for more."

"Great Upstate location! Very welcoming."

"great stay"