Find hotels in Eagle Bay, NY from SAR 384

"The only thing missing from this place is food and a hot tub. But we went during winter and it’s the off season - but man did we enjoy our stay. Absolutely lovely. "

"This cottage made for a fun and easy family get-away recently. It's conveniently located - close to shops, restaurants, movie theater, and the public beach in Old Forge, as well as hiking trails within walking distance or a short drive. Also very close to McCauley Mountain for skiing and mountain biking. The cottage was super clean from top to bottom. Check-in/out was easy and the owners were easy to contact if/when needed."

"Our off season stay was perfect and quiet."

"We had an amazing quiet time at Eagle Bay Village. The room was perfect for my husband and I and the view of Fourth Lake was great."

"Love this place! Great owners!"

"We are a family of four with two children, ages 6 and 9. We enjoyed our two nights at this cabin. The upstairs bedroom configuration was fun for the kids. A little bit of Netflix and PBS kids when it was particularly rainy over the weekend, as well as the suitcase-full of games the kids brought with us. We weren't able to hike Bald Mntn as planned because of the rain, but the home's location was well settled in low-traffic side streets that permitted us to get in a nice walk/hike when the rain broke for a few hours. "

"Great location. "

"We had a great time! We booked the place to come ride snowmobiles with some friends for the weekend, the house was perfect size for 4 adults and 2 kids, we could have fit a couple more people for sure! It was clean and nicely set up. We would definitely book here again. "

"Great place to stay! Park your sled at your door."