Find 2 Star Hotels in Shirley, NY from SAR 335

"Great location very close to shopping area"

"It was very comfortable and peaceful. A great place to stay. It's pricey, but everything on the island is these days. The staff are all really friendly and helpful."

"The room was comfortable. However there is know coffee machine.and no gym."

"Nice place"

"The owner (?) is incredibly friendly. "

"The room was absolutely disgusting. the smell in the room was awfull! there was mold all over the ceiling near the bathroom, the sink and bath tub had rust all over it. and the ice bucket had old food in it. thankfully the girl a tthe front desk gave us a new one. the side walks are all cracked and wobbly, but this place needs to be condemned its not safe and is a healthy hazard. DO NOT STAY HERE BY ANY MEANS NECCESSARY"

"This is our 4th stay at this property and each time it is better and better. The accommodations are beautiful, the waterfront property is gorgeous and the staff is super friendly!"

"A rustic setting but everything was modern and clean. It’s easy to get to and near the bay."

"There is not one human being taking care of the property. That means it is NOT A HOTEL. I DON'T WANT CODES TEXTED TO ME IN ORDER TO OPEN DOORS. The only thing you could hear of humanity was the endless LOUD NOISE til 2am from the ground level bar that these rooms are directly above. Just awful. "

"Decent motel "

"N/A"

"I'd like the quaintness about it I like the view. The location was fabulous"