Find 2 Star Hotels in Portlandville, NY from SAR 268

"My family very much enjoyed our stay here! The rooms were clean, the staff was friendly, and it was easy to get to. The proximity to Cooperstown worked very well for us, as did the ability to fish right across the street from the property - my son and I spent a good deal of time casting from the docks. We would stay here again in a heartbeat!"

"Awesome Hotel & Staff!!"

"Everything was wonderful except the over night temperature of room was stifling hot. We don’t know if there was a way to turn that down. Even after fireplace had been off for several hours it was terrible I ended up opening windows around 2am and that helped a bit. That is only complaint—and maybe it was just our lack of knowing if there was a thermostat. Otherwise it was amazing "

"I found this property last Fall when I was in town on short notice. Being a small businessman myself, I always try and support non franchise hotels when possible. The Railroad Inn looked good on Expedia so I took the chance. I loved it! Super accommodating staff when I needed late check in, and a clean room with a comfortable bed. When we decided to do a weekend in Cooperstown with friends, I remembered this place and brought it up. We stayed two nights and everyone loved it. The suite with the...

"Phenomenal place!! Breakfast was amazing and the owner and his family were very nice!"

"It was a beautiful place to stay! "

"Beautiful location on the lake. Easy to find, helpful staff"

"We were just disappointed that the Bistro was closed on Saturday. "

"Hotel staff was great. They gave us sleds to use on the hills next to the hotel. Hotel could use some updates but it was clean. The breakfast was great but the staff that took care of replenishing the breakfast and keeping things clean went above and beyond. He was up wiping tables constantly and making sure everything was clean and organized at the buffet, he even offered to make my son a special breakfast the following day but we were leaving. Very impressed! "

"I checked in last night about 10 o’clock. I was greeted warmly by the clerk on the desk and my check was processed quickly and professionally. I found the room to be comfortable and parking was easy."

"Young lady at front desk was very accommodating!!!"