Find Beach Hotels in Water Mill, NY

"We loved this house and Margaux was a great host! Communication was easy and excellent. We loved every minute! Thanks!"

"The hosts are great, stayed in touch with us before and during the stay. Always available and responsive to our questions and needs. Will definitely come back."

"Kathy is absolutely one of the best host’s we’ve ever experienced. The home was perfect- clean as a whistle and full of thoughtful treats upon arrival. The pool is wonderful, and we had plenty of space in the house for all four of us to spread out. Five stars!!!"

"Great stay and property. The house is private and a great set up for hanging by the pool. Working with the Diana was great as well! We are excited to return soon!"

"Our crew were 7 adults and 7 children and there was adequate space to sleep and relax. Lots of toys for the kids and they spent a lot of time in the den area playing. Outside pool is heated, major deck and back porch space with plenty of places & chairs to sit. Super stocked kitchen and owner always available. The place was very clean. The real “kicker” was after we left, I notified him that there was a small diamond, expensive necklace missing, he got back to us the next day and told us that...

"House was very very nice. It was 8 people in my group and we all fit comfortably. Perfect wooded quiet location. House was very very clean with a supply of toilet paper, paper towels and trash bags. Beds and linen were very comfortable. House host was wonderful to communicate with quick responses. Everything in the house was functional, nothing was broken. We loved The Hamptons and the experience to stay here ! and "

" The house was beautiful and perfectly equipped, with thoughtful touches like our favorite Le Labo samples in the bathrooms. Our only slight disappointment was the timing—check-in at 4pm on Friday and check-out at 10am (extended to 12pm) on Sunday made the weekend feel a bit short. Additionally, being right on Montauk Highway made access at night feel a little tricky. That said, everything else was perfect, and we truly enjoyed our stay!"