The Best Hotels Closest to Toy Museum in Beaver Island for 2025

Starry Night. Spacious and relaxing guesthouse. WiFi. 2 miles from town.

5/5 Excellent

Beautiful and relaxing getaway!

"Bryan and Becca were great hosts! They made the check in and out process as easy as it could possibly be, and they were always easy to reach over the phone. The guest house had everything we needed - all we had to bring was our standard luggage and a few groceries. The house was very very clean and thoughtfully decorated. They also included a basket of maps, pamphlets, and more for us to really make the most of our trip. Overall, we simply couldn't have asked for a better stay. If I could give them more than 5 stars I would!"

A verified traveler stayed at Starry Night. Spacious and relaxing guesthouse. WiFi. 2 miles from town.

Posted 6 days ago

Captain's Quarters @The Boat Shop - Overlooking Paradise Bay

5/5 Excellent

Beaver island

"We loved our stay on Beaver Island. Carol was a a fantastic host. It was raining when our ferry got in so she so nice and able to picked us up and drove us to our accommodations which because we were staying off season were ready early. She was very helpful the next day when we wanted to rent a car as well so we could explore more of the island. Our accommodations were clean and quiet and on a gorgeous part of the island. "

A verified traveler stayed at Captain's Quarters @The Boat Shop - Overlooking Paradise Bay

Posted 8 days ago

5/5 Excellent

"Beautiful home with interesting architecture, barely visible from the road hidden away, close to town and very cozy. Host was very communicable and was able to open the place for us early in the season. "

A verified traveler stayed at Beautiful Beaver Island getaway

Posted 8 days ago

Sunny Oaks. Bright, beautiful, in town. Wifi.

5/5 Excellent

Awesome! Place to stay when visiting the island

"Becca and Byian were great. Really a nice place. Very conveniently located to downtown. We brought bikes and were able to use the bikes for the northern part of the island. We took a rental to reach down south. But you do need to be up north when you visit the island cuz you're going to want to be near the grocery store and restaurants. And you can't really do much better than this place. It was great! Thanks, Becca and Bryan "

A verified traveler stayed at Sunny Oaks. Bright, beautiful, in town. Wifi.

Posted 9 days ago

5/5 Excellent

Cozy, quiet, but easy access to everything.

"Great place, good for a winter getaway for one or two people. Would be equally good for a family with 3 kids in the summer. Basically right next door to the only grocery store on the island. Walking distance to everything in town. Sure, you can find places on the island that are out in the middle of the woods. Probably for triple the price. But don't let the location fool you. It's Beaver Island. It's ALL quiet and remote relative to what the vast majority of people are used to. Even in town you can interact with as many, or a few people as you'd like. Many other island options are just not feasible without a vehicle. This location is perfect for those who don't want the added expense of renting or bringing one over on the boat. "

A verified traveler stayed at Convenient Beaver Island Location

Posted 5 months ago

5/5 Excellent

Great location and a nice house

"Everything was better than expected. There's plenty of room, the view is awesome and we had a good time. The only negative is that there's no closets in the bedrooms. It's still a great place and not a deal breaker, I'd stay here again for sure. "

A verified traveler stayed at Lakefront Cottage on Soft Sand

Posted 6 months ago

5/5 Excellent

Rustic Cabin Getaway

"Beautiful location right on the beach for solitude and dark skies experience. "

A verified traveler stayed at Rustic Authentic Michigan Log Cabin

Posted 7 months ago

5/5 Excellent

Our Island Stay

"Everything was just as described and the location was perfect!"

A verified traveler stayed at Beaver Island - Trails End

Posted 7 months ago

Sunsets, Sandy Beach and Seclusion; enjoy them all at this stunning lake house

5/5 Excellent

Wonderful house and hosts

"We loved our stay at Jon and Carolyn’s home on Beaver Island! It was spacious, tastefully decorated with an artist’s eye for soothing colors and detail (Carolyn is an artist), clean, comfortable and well-equipped with pretty much everything we needed for a relaxing visit and cooking wonderful family meals, as we love doing. The location couldn’t have been more idyllic. The home is located on the secluded Mrs. Redding’s Trail, right on Lake Michigan. The windows offer a magical view of sand and rock formations on the water, with sea gulls, eagles, deer, swans, woodpeckers and other wildlife delighting us every day! We appreciated taking lovely walks right outside the door, with the road opening to beautiful nature trails and historic sights where we could enjoy the magnificent autumn colors. We would recommend this home to anyone and hope to return next year!"

A verified traveler stayed at Sunsets, Sandy Beach and Seclusion; enjoy them all at this stunning lake house

Posted 7 months ago

Find hotels near Toy Museum, Beaver Island

Check prices for these dates

Filter by

Compare hotels close to Toy Museum with room rates, reviews, and availability. Most hotels are fully refundable.

Hotels near Other Beaver Island Attractions

Tunnel of Trees

Beaver Island Community Center

The Marine Museum

Old Mormon Print Shop Museum

Millecoquins Point

Top of the Lake Snowmobile Museum

Recent reviews of Toy Museum hotels

Starry Night. Spacious and relaxing guesthouse. WiFi. 2 miles from town.

Captain's Quarters @The Boat Shop - Overlooking Paradise Bay

Beautiful Beaver Island getaway

Sunny Oaks. Bright, beautiful, in town. Wifi.

Convenient Beaver Island Location

Lakefront Cottage on Soft Sand

Rustic Authentic Michigan Log Cabin

Beaver Island - Trails End

Sunsets, Sandy Beach and Seclusion; enjoy them all at this stunning lake house

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

Hotels near popular Beaver Island Attractions

Other Hotels near Toy Museum, Beaver Island

More Hotel Options in Toy Museum

Explore more hotels