Find Beach Hotels in Shelter Island, NY

"The location and room were great for a beach hotel. No room service and no coffee in the room The restaurant opens late and doesn’t serve breakfast. Otherwise amazing. "

"This is the most magical property with a gorgeous pool, beautiful large trees, a pond and a badmitten court. My two children loved it. The property was a 3-4 minute drive from everything and yet felt totally isolated and removed from everything. I will say that the house was more cozy than we expected as the bedrooms upstairs were a steep walk and there was only one bathroom for the entire house. But we made do and had a lovely time."

"We had a wonderful stay in Shleter island and are definitely planning to be back. The house is beautiful, very well equipped, comfortable and welcoming. The hosts were helpful and the location is amazing."

"Myself and my sons had a great week on the island . We loved being so close to Shell beach. The house is well appointed and has everything you need."

"Lovely getaway in a very sweet house. Property manager very responsive. Perfect location."

"We stayed in November for a funeral on SI. The house and grounds were lovely with a fence in backyard. TVs in most rooms. Plenty of space. Large gorgeous kitchen open to sitting area, separate living space and large table in dining room. Plenty of bathrooms. Four bedrooms, cozy beds. I would definitely stay again. Thank you."

"The communications with the owner couldn't have been better. They made every accommodation that we asked. The house was completely as advertised and clean. We had a great time and would love to book the house again in the future. Highly recommend for a quick getaway of the City! Especially during Covid. Thanks again!"