Search Vacation Homes in New Haven

Plan, book, stay with confidence

Be picky

Search almost a million properties worldwide

Treat yourself

Change your mind

Book hotels with free cancellation

Check availability on Vacation Homes in New Haven

Compare 59 Vacation Homes in New Haven with updated reviews, rates, and availability.

Phoenix Vacation Rental | 4BR | 1.5BA | 1,440 Sq Ft | Stairs Required

"It felt like home away from home."

Watch the sunset while enjoying the fire pit with free, unlimited firewood.

"Great place on the lake, very well kept and property is ran very well. Great communication from owner and excellent experience "

"This property was perfect for 4 adults. Downtown was walkable and we enjoyed dining at 3 of the owners suggested restaurants. The house was clean and quiet in a nice area. "

"Myself and 2 other stayed for weekend of fishing. Good location - the house was just what we needed to crash after long day on the river. "

SAR 717 total

includes taxes & fees

23 Nov - 24 Nov

"Everything as described, great communication, super clean, super enjoyable! Can't wait to stay again! "

"Just what we needed for Oswego family weekend! Will definitely be back! Thank you!"

"This place was just right for our group of fishermen. We fished the lake for a week and this was a great place to make home base. Easy to get to, lots of parking, clean, and cozy."

"Everything was amazing from the cottage cleanliness and communication! Will definitely stay here again!"

"Loved the sun room a true Birds Eye view. Enjoyed the birds. Very clean and neat. Very accommodating. Trip to the beach for sun sets at Southwick State Park amazing. Highly recommend Lakeview Pond trail to a 13 mile isolated beach."

"We will be nack agaoin"

"Verry good"

"The house has everything you need for a Salmon River trip. Good acces to river and dining options. House had plenty of room for the five of us. "

Altmar Vacation Rental | 4BR | 1.5BA | 2,000 Sq Ft | Steps Required to Enter

"Perfect space for sharing time together. Written instructions in the home are not the same as instructions on the website. "

"Our purpose was to spend time with family and friends and our college kids. The house had plenty of room to sleep, cook and play games. Central location and good parking. The host was so easy to contact. We will absolutely go back."

"My family and i had the best time here. I would ecommend 100%"

"I highly recommend a stay here if you get the chance. Our hosts thought of everything we could need to make our stay comfortable and enjoyable. The lake view is spectacular and just private enough to never want to leave. Hopefully next time we are in the area we can stay here again!"

So beautiful and peaceful on the dunes near the Great Lake Ontario.

"The yard was very nice but it was difficult to get the kayaks to the water. The place was immaculate."

"Large house, nice location "

"This is nice place and the view to the lake is beautiful."

SAR 2,339 total

includes taxes & fees

23 Nov - 24 Nov

"Just overall a great property to stay. "

SAR 1,307 total

includes taxes & fees

23 Nov - 24 Nov

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Other property types in New Haven

"Thank you for another great stay. "

"We have stayed with Brian and Andrea for several years now and we booked a week again for November 2025. We love this cabin. It works great for us. It is clean, comfortable and the hosts are very responsive and great people. There are many places to stay around Altmar and Pulaski but we love this cabin. This is a 5 star+ cabin!!"