Great place if you know what to expect. Sutton's Place is a classic New England bed and breakfast, only without the breakfast. You are renting a room in a historic house, not a hotel. The owners are very friendly, accommodating and gave great recommendations. They live in the house as well so they are easy to find if you need anything. Our room was clean and comfortable with a shared bathroom. The bathroom was shared with our adjacent room, and had a door into each room which could be locked for privacy. There is also a separate unattached bathroom down the hall, so we never had an issue of waiting for a bathroom. The location is great, within walking distance for the little downtown where there are some great restaurants and bars. We stayed here for a Stratton ski trip. The mountain is an easy 20 min drive (or 35 min in a blizzard) away. It is nice to stay in a real town instead of the very small villages closer to Stratton.
You should expect an experience similar to a bed and breakfast or an Airbnb room in a private home. If you are expecting homey comforts and not a chain hotel, you will have a great time! Would definitely stay again.