Search Cottages in Kelleys Island

"This is the nicest cottage. Tucked away and very private and peaceful. Host was easy to contact and gave us great advice on what to bring. Would rent this for sure again!! Great hideaway and suggest it for Fall as well. The Island was great to see without the hussle and bussle of summer!!"

"Had a great time staying here for our fishing trip."

"The stay was very nice the time that we was there. We were so busy going to cedar point. It is located in a nice neighborhood and the cost of the stay is very reasonable. We will be coming back next year and if it’s available to rent when we come we will definitely rent it again. Pleased with everything. Thanks for opening up your home to us. 🙂"

"It was so relaxing and sweet getting my mother and her sister together. And my sister, my cousin and myself celebrating our birthdays and enjoying each others company away from the big city noise. The perfect girls-trip. "

"We had a great weekend at Stargazer Haven with extended family. Kate has done a great job updating the house. There were tons of comfortable beds, kitchen had plenty of dishes, pots, pans, etc., and there were some nice extras—pickleball paddles, mini golf clubs, chalk, etc. This is a great home for families on a quiet street. The location couldn’t be better—close to the lake and downtown area. Kate was really helpful when we had questions. We highly recommend this home. "

"Nice place to stay. Was clean and stocked with necessities. My only complaint was that it was cold/drafty even with the heat on. The November weather was cold and windy during our stay."

"I highly recommend a stay at "Lovely Lakeside"! Everything was exactly as advertised--or better! The location is perfect--a quick walk to the lake, The Patio, and everything else downtown. The rooms were clean and comfortable, and we enjoyed having two separate living areas for a group of six adults and one toddler. The deck and backyard were perfect for toddler play in the afternoon and grownup conversation in the evening. The house was well-equipped for cooking, the bathrooms were clean...