Search Cabin Rentals in Shelter Island

"The staff at Baron's was extremely accomodating - from dog friednly room options to placing a crib in our room before arrival for our newborn. Every request was met swiftly and executed well. Highly recommend. Easy to walk to downtown Sag if you don't want to deal with parking, and vast array of amenities on site were lovely. "

"Beautiful place to stay, friendly and profesional staff, great room with nice balcony very comfortable suite. Will go back for sure. "

"Our 3 rd visit here- always a wonderful experience "

"Very nice big room. Convenient to everything."

"Great room. Clean. Quiet. Affordable."

"The whole experience was ready and kind. "

"The breakfast coffee was sub par. The omelette was very good."

"Lovely property .... The dinner was great . Room service was very convenient and fast . The spa was wonderful Justine was amazing with the massage I felt so relaxed after. Our pedicures the next day were equally amazing, my feet are so soft and clean my polish is neat. I will definitely be back for a massage and relaxing overnight trip . "

"This motel look property is absolutely gorgeous, the details in the spacious rooms are stunning. The staff was very friendly and welcoming. I can’t wait to go back in the summer. "