Resorts in Rum Cay

"This was our second stay at Bonefish Valhalla Villa and it was just as great as the first. The setting is fantastic and the house is comfortable, well-equipped, and clean. The house manager is really helpful. Loved the whole experience!"

"Really beautiful location. Hope to come back soon."

"My wife and I stayed at Serenity for a week and it wasn’t long enough!! The property is just as listed. If you are looking for somewhere to “check out” this is the place. Jim and Loretta are fantastic hosts and are available for any questions or requests. Thank you for an incredible week and we will be back!!"

"This is our second time at Blue Crescent and it’s simply our favorite place in the world! The house is beautiful and super clean and the beach is amazing. Chuck and Teresa are super responsive and ensured that we had everything we need. We hope to be back for a third time soon!"

"Absolutely wonderful Cottage!!"

"This property is absolutely beautiful! Hardly anyone on the beach, very laid back. Not everything is perfect, our safe didn't work, could only lock door from inside villa, they didn't have the proper tip to inflate our floaties, but you have to remember you are in a remote area. You also have to remember you are on island time!! No one is in a hurry. We loved this place and will be back."

"We were looking for a place to stay that was comfortable but far away from resorts and other people. That is exactly what we got! Nancy and her caretaker were both very responsive and helpful. For those new to Cat Island they both provide important and helpful context on how to prepare for the trip and what to expect- even including tips on getting there from Nassau. The setting is just so gorgeous and you have like a 100m of beach to yourself. I think in two weeks we saw three people. When we felt like some company we walked 100m to the Pink Chicken bar for some excellent fish and conch... and a few beers. The snorkelling off the beach was fantastic. So many fish including a very large and curious baracuda. The house itself is completely modern and has everything one could ask for. We will be back."

"We really enjoyed our stay at Banana Wind. I highly recommend having Mr. Harrison King prepare dinner for your first night. I recommend renting an SUV or something other than a car. The roads are terrible…everywhere "

"Cottage was exactly as we'd hoped - secluded (careful on the dirt road in; potholes abound), quiet, and just steps from the beach. House had all the amenities we could possibly have asked for, and the property manager proved professional and helpful. Beach is gorgeous, with clear shallow water and craggy coves for exploring with kids. Location is perfect; central to (20 min. drive) plenty of restaurants, a well-stocked market, and lots of stuff to do. Communication with owners was fast and easy.Everyone we met was friendly and delightful, safety never felt like an issue at all. Only deducted a star from "location and neighborhood" because on windy days the beach seems to accumulate a lot of trash brought in by the trade winds. Unfortunate and somewhat of a downer, but certainly no fault of the owners, or the Bahamas for that matter. Would definitely stay again. Highly recommend. "