Search Cottages in Middle Cay

"Our stay at Daddy Joe’s was absolutely delightful! The accommodations are beautifully designed with a keen eye for detail, featuring nice little touches throughout the room that made our stay extra special. The recently renovated rooms are not only stylish but also equipped with everything you need—good working AC, coffee and tea, water bottles, and even a welcome gift with drinks and snacks. Upon arrival, we were treated to a welcome cocktail at the bar, which was a lovely surprise. The owner, Tiffany, truly made us feel at home and like part of her family. Her warmth and hospitality added a personal touch that made our experience unforgettable. We celebrated New Year at their restaurant and were thoroughly impressed by the delicious food. The meal was a highlight of our stay, and the festive atmosphere made it even more enjoyable. The beach, Gaulding’s Cay, is just a very short walk away and is absolutely gorgeous. It’s the perfect spot for a relaxing day by the sea. The entire staff at Daddy Joe’s was incredibly friendly and lovely, making us feel welcomed at every turn. We can highly recommend staying at Daddy Joe’s for anyone looking for a cozy, welcoming, and beautiful place to stay. It was truly a fantastic experience!"

"We had an absolutely lovely time. We came here on our honeymoon and they upgraded us the honeymoon suite free of charge. Literally the nicest people ever. Tingham is an incredible option if you're staying on Harbour island. Baby Ruby is a gem of a person. We will definitely be coming back in the future. "

"I highly recommend staying here. It was wonderful!"

"Clean, safe and friendly staff. Wonderful stay!"

"Most incredible vacation ever. The place, scenery, people, April, her husband and Brandi were like family. Not one complaint. Spectacular experience. Ready to go back. Didn’t want to leave ever. "

"The Sea Spray cottage was accurately represented in the listing. We saw sting rays from the deck, and watched every sunrise and sunset. The house was stocked with the basics, but also had books and maps of the island beaches and snorkeling spots, left by the owners or past guests. We contributed a map to the pile when we left. Couldn’t have asked for more. It was gorgeous and felt completely private, with the safety of knowing the owner was close by if needed. Highly recommend. "

"We had a great time here. Owner was very responsive to any issues ( including a flat tire on the cart that was promptly repaired). Highly recommend renting here. "

"The salt box is divine! The property is so beautiful. Every space is gorgeous. We enjoyed every moment here. Perfect honeymoon location"

"Island living with all of the amenities. The staff is very friendly and accomodating."